The Impact of Sustainability on Contractor Selection Criteria in Construction Projects: A Comprehensive Review

Document Type : Review Paper

Authors

1 Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Menoufia University, Egypt

2 Professor of Reinforced Concrete Structures at Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Menoufia University, Egypt

3 Professor of Projects Management at Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Future University

4 Professor of Strength and Testing Material at Department of Civil Engineering, and Dean of the Faculty of Engineering, Menoufia University, Egypt

Abstract

This paper investigates the increasing emphasis on sustainable practices within the construction industry and its impact on contractor selection criteria. Recognizing the pivotal role of contractors in project success, this study examines the shift in selection criteria towards incorporating sustainability considerations for both project completion and promoting environmentally responsible construction practices. Through a structured review of literature from documented databases and prominent journals published between 2010 and 2024, this research aims to achieve three primary objectives: first, to delineate and classify conventional criteria employed in contractor selection processes; second, to highlight the emergence of contemporary criteria prioritizing sustainability, particularly in the context of green building projects; and third, to comprehensively analyze the current state of knowledge and identify research gaps concerning the influence of sustainability on contractor selection, utilizing structured review methodologies. The key finding of this research indicates that the contractor selection process is significantly influenced by sustainability considerations. When selecting contractors for green building projects, it is essential to integrate sustainability-related criteria, such as environmental and social factors, along with contractors' qualifications in green construction, into the traditional evaluation framework. This study identified a primary limitation: despite reviewing 70 research papers, it is not possible to definitively claim that all relevant publications on contractor selection were examined. The findings of this study provide valuable insights for future research endeavors aimed at developing comprehensive contractor selection models that integrate sustainable criteria alongside traditional criteria.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

 [1] Mahdi, I. M., Riley, M. J., Fereig, S. M., & Alex, A. P. (2002). A multi‐criteria approach to contractor selection. Engineering, construction and architectural management, 9(1), 29-37.
[2] Ansah, N. B., Aidoo, I., & Agbevade, J. (2023). Assessment of Environmental Knowledge: The Case of the Ghanaian Contractor. In Technological Innovation Driving Sustainable Entrepreneurial Growth in Developing Nations (pp. 350-363). IGI Global.
[3] United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. (2023). the sustainable development goals report 2016. UN.
[4] Lima, L., Trindade, E., Alencar, L., Alencar, M., & Silva, L. (2021). Sustainability in the construction industry: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Cleaner Production, 289, 125730.
[5] Jiang, J., He, Z., & Ke, C. (2023). Construction contractors’ carbon emissions reduction intention: a study based on structural equation model. Sustainability, 15(14), 10894.
[6] Falana, J., Osei-Kyei, R., & Tam, V. W. (2023). Towards achieving a net zero carbon building: A review of key stakeholders and their roles in net zero carbon building whole life cycle. Journal of Building Engineering, 108223.
[7] Albino, V., & Berardi, U. (2012). Green buildings and organizational changes in Italian case studies. Business strategy and the Environment, 21(6), 387-400.
[8] Shan, M., Liu, W. Q., Hwang, B. G., & Lye, J. M. (2020). Critical success factors for small contractors to conduct green building construction projects in Singapore: identification and comparison with large contractors. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 27(8), 8310-8322.
[9] Zavadskas, E. K., Vilutienė, T., Turskis, Z., & Šaparauskas, J. (2014). Multi-criteria analysis of Projects’ performance in construction. Archives of civil and mechanical engineering, 14, 114-121.
[10] Oyegoke, A. S., & Al Kiyumi, N. (2017). The causes, impacts and mitigations of delay in megaprojects in the Sultanate of Oman. Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction, 22(3), 286-302.
[11] Powmya, A., Abidin, N. Z., & Azizi, N. S. M. (2023). Determination of contractor strategies in delivering construction projects in Oman. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries, 28(1), 293-316.
[12] Jain, S., Jauhar, S. K., & Piyush. (2024). A machine-learning-based framework for contractor selection and order allocation in public construction projects considering sustainability, risk, and safety. Annals of Operations Research, 1-43.
[13] El-Sayegh, S. M., Basamji, M., Haj Ahmad, A., & Zarif, N. (2021). Key contractor selection criteria for green construction projects in the UAE. International Journal of Construction Management, 21(12), 1240-1250. Green construction
[14] Asaad, A., & El-Sayegh, S. M. (2021). Key criteria for selecting green suppliers for construction projects in the UAE. Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction, 26(2), 201-218.
[15] Gu, J., Guo, F., Peng, X., & Wang, B. (2023). Green and sustainable construction industry: A systematic literature review of the contractor’s green construction capability. Buildings, 13(2), 470.
[16] Acheamfour, V. K., Adjei-Kumi, T., & Kissi, E. (2023). Contractor selection: a review of qualification and pre-qualification systems. International Journal of Construction Management, 23(2), 338-348.
[17] Khoso, A. R., & Md Yusof, A. (2020). Extended review of contractor selection in construction projects. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 47(7), 771-789.
[18] Khoso, A. R., Yusof, A. M., Chen, Z. S., Skibniewski, M. J., Chin, K. S., Khahro, S. H., & Sohu, S. (2022). Comprehensive analysis of state-of-the-art contractor selection models in construction environment-A critical review and future call. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 79, 101137.
[19] Kog, F., & Yaman, H. (2014). A Meta classification and analysis of contractor selection and prequalification. Procedia Engineering, 85, 302-310.
[20] Acheamfour, V. K., Kissi, E., Adjei-Kumi, T., & Adinyira, E. (2020). Review of empirical arguments on contractor pre-qualification criteria. Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology, 18(1), 70-83.
 [21] Hanelt, A., Bohnsack, R., Marz, D., & Antunes Marante, C. (2021). A systematic review of the literature on digital transformation: Insights and implications for strategy and organizational change. Journal of management studies, 58(5), 1159-1197.
[22] Danese, P., Manfè, V., & Romano, P. (2018). A systematic literature review on recent lean research: state‐of‐the‐art and future directions. International Journal of Management Reviews, 20(2), 579-605.
[23] Vrontis, D., & Christofi, M. (2021). R&D internationalization and innovation: A systematic review, integrative framework and future research directions. Journal of Business Research, 128, 812-823.
[24] Persson, U. (2009). Management of sustainability in construction works. Lund University. ‏
[25] Lorenz, D., Lützkendorf, T., 2011. Sustainability and property valuation: systematisation of existing approaches and recommendations for future action. J. Property Investment Finance 29 (6), 644- 676.
[26] Lélé, S. M. (1991). Sustainable development: a critical review. World development, 19(6), 607-621.‏
[27] Halliday, S. (2008). Sustainable construction. Routledge.
[28] Gallopín, G. C. (2003). A systems approach to sustainability and sustainable development (Vol. 64). United Nations Publications.
[29] Guido, A., Farzaneh, H., & Guo, J. (2012). Social Actions of Strategic Sustainable Development. ‏
[30] Laosirihongthong, T., Samaranayake, P., & Nagalingam, S. (2019). A holistic approach to supplier evaluation and order allocation towards sustainable procurement. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 26(8), 2543-2573. Sustainable procurement
[31] Borujeni, M. P., & Gitinavard, H. (2017). Evaluating the sustainable mining contractor selection problems: An imprecise last aggregation preference selection index method. Journal of Sustainable Mining, 16(4), 207-218.
[32] Gurgun, A. P., & Koc, K. (2020). Contractor prequalification for green buildings—evidence from Turkey. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 27(6), 1377-1400.
[33] Parsa, M., Taheri, S., & Taheri, S. (2018). Employing multiple criteria decision making to evaluate HSE performance of contractor's case study: Lorestan Province Gas Company. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management.
[34] Luong-Duc, L., & Do-Duy, L. (2023, July). Using “Choosing by Advantages” Method to Select Contractor for Design and Build Projects Toward Sustainable Construction. In The International Conference on Sustainable Civil Engineering and Architecture (pp. 690-699). Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
[35] Cai, J., Li, Z., Dou, Y., Teng, Y., & Yuan, M. (2023). Contractor selection for green buildings based on the fuzzy Kano model and TOPSIS: A developer satisfaction perspective. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 30(10), 5073-5108.
[36] Christhia, M. L., Khair, F., & Saputro, H. W. (2023). Optimizing Civil Contractor Selection for Sustainable Community Maintenance Projects Using Open Tender Systems. In E3S Web of Conferences (Vol. 426, p. 01079). EDP Sciences.
[37] El-Sayegh, S. M., AbdRaboh, T., Elian, D., ElJarad, N., & Ahmad, Y. (2022). Developing a bi-parameter bidding model integrating price and sustainable construction practices. International Journal of Construction Management, 22(11), 2191-2198.
[38] Gao, G. X. (2018). Sustainable winner determination for public-private partnership infrastructure projects in multi-attribute reverse auctions. Sustainability, 10(11), 4129.
[39] Liu, B., Yang, X., Huo, T., Shen, G. Q., & Wang, X. (2017). A linguistic group decision-making framework for bid evaluation in mega public projects considering carbon dioxide emissions reduction. Journal of Cleaner Production, 148, 811-825.
[40] Setiawan, H., Ervianto, W. I., & Han, A. L. (2019, June). Green Construction Capability Model (GCCM) for Contracting Companies. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 290, No. 1, p. 012159). IOP Publishing.
[41] Singh, P., & Ruparathna, R. (2020). Construction project proposal evaluation under uncertainty: A fuzzy-based approach. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 47(3), 291-300.
[42] Yan, L., Ye, K., & Jiang, W. (2015). Sustainable construction indicators: An examination of clients’ requirements in tender documents. In ICCREM 2015 (pp. 380-388).
 [43] Yan, M. R. (2015). Project-based market competition and policy implications for sustainable developments in building and construction sectors. Sustainability, 7(11), 15423-15448.
 [44] Wirahadikusumah, R. D., & Ario, D. (2015). A readiness assessment model for Indonesian contractors in implementing sustainability principles. International Journal of Construction Management, 15(2), 126-136.
[45] Liao, P. C., Tsenguun, G., & Liang, L. W. (2016). Development of social responsibility evaluation framework of construction projects: a multi-stakeholder's perspective. Procedia Engineering, 145, 234-241.
[46] Tayeh, B. A., Durdyev, S., Abuzuhri, I. O., Hosseini, M. R., & Thurnell, D. (2019). Contractors' attitudes towards the factors affecting sustainability performance: Evidence from Palestine. Business Strategy & Development, 2(3), 173-179.
[47] Xia, B., Chen, Q., Xu, Y., Li, M., & Jin, X. (2015). Design-build contractor selection for public sustainable buildings. Journal of management in engineering, 31(5), 04014070.
[48] GURGUN, A. P., & OZBEK, M. E. (2017). FACTORS AFFECTING THE SELECTION OF CONTRACTORS IN GREEN BUILDING PROJECTS
[49] Shamsuddin Sabri, I., & Aziz, R. A. (2021, February). Towards Better Contractor Performance to Achieve Sustainable Road Project Development. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 641, No. 1, p. 012017).
[50] Zhao, L., Liu, W., & Wu, Y. (2020). Bid evaluation decision for major project based on analytic hierarchy process and data envelopment analysis cross-efficiency model. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing, 11, 3639-3647.
[51] Ahn, C., Peña-Mora, F., Lee, S., & Arboleda, C. A. (2013). Consideration of the environmental cost in construction contracting for public works: A+ C and A+ B+ C bidding methods. Journal of Management in Engineering, 29(1), 86-94.
[52] Hsueh, S. L., & Yan, M. R. (2013). A multimethodology contractor assessment model for facilitating green innovation: the view of energy and environmental protection. The Scientific World Journal, 2013(1), 624340.
[53] Amoako Sarpong, F., Kissi, E., Acheamfour, V. K., Abu, I. M., & Eluerkeh, K. (2023). Establishing the Economic Sustainability Criteria for Assessing Tenders in the Procurement of Building Works. Public Works Management & Policy, 1087724X231221432.
[54] Cao, Q., Esangbedo, M. O., Bai, S., & Esangbedo, C. O. (2019). Grey SWARA-FUCOM weighting method for contractor selection MCDM problem: A case study of floating solar panel energy system installation. Energies, 12(13), 2481.
[55] Zhou, W., Liu, M., & Xu, Z. (2021). Evolutionary computation of the generalized hesitant fuzzy envelopment analysis and its application in the contractor selection of green building project. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 70(10), 3622-3636.
[56] Xia, B., Skitmore, M., Zuo, J., Zhao, Z., & Nepal, M. (2014). Defining sustainability requirements for design-build (DB) contractor selection in public sector projects. In Proceedings of the 18th International Symposium on Advancement of Construction Management and Real Estate (pp. 59-66). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
[57] Naji, K. K., Gunduz, M., & Falamarzi, M. H. (2022). Assessment of construction project contractor selection success factors considering their interconnections. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 26(9), 3677-3690.
[58] Ulubeyli, S., Kazaz, A., & Arslan, V. (2017). A structured selection process for small and medium enterprises in construction industry: case of international projects. Periodicals of engineering and natural sciences, 5(3).
[59] Husin, A. E., Soehari, T. D., & Prabowo, Y. S. (2019). Analytical hierarchy process (AHP) implementation in determining document evaluation criteria of post qualification E-tendering knockout phase. Int J Eng Adv Technol, 8(6), 160-165.
 [60] Zainuddin, A., Setiawan, A. D., & Hidayatno, A. (2021, May). A Conceptual Model for Contractor Assessment System in the Electricity Project with Tender. In Proceedings of the 4th Asia Pacific Conference on Research in Industrial and Systems Engineering (pp. 458-463).
[61] Khoso, A. R., Yusof, A. M., Khahro, S. H., Abidin, N. I. A. B., & Memon, N. A. (2022). Automated two-stage continuous decision support model using exploratory factor analysis-MACBETH-SMART: an application of contractor selection in public sector construction. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing, 1-31.
[62] Dissanayake, N., Xia, B., Skitmore, M., Trigunarsyah, B., & Menadue, V. (2023). Ranked generic criteria for EPC contractor selection. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 30(10), 4933-4954.
[63] Sun, S., Zhou, S., & Zhao, X. (2013). Analysis of Construction contractor selection and evaluation based on AHP and GRA. In ICCREM 2013: Construction and Operation in the Context of Sustainability (pp. 36-44).
[64] Polat, G. (2016). Subcontractor selection using the integration of the AHP and PROMETHEE methods. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 22(8), 1042-1054.
[65] Acheamfour, V. K., Kissi, E., & Adjei-Kumi, T. (2019). Ascertaining the impact of contractors' pre-qualification criteria on project success criteria. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 26(4), 618-632.
[66] Kog, F., & Yaman, H. (2016). A multi-agent systems-based contractor pre-qualification model. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 23(6), 709-726. Simulation
[67] Okereke, R. A., Pepple, D. I., & Ihekweme, N. M. (2022). Assessment of the major contractors’ selection criteria and their impacts in civil engineering construction projects. ITEGAM-JETIA, 8(36), 4-13.
[68] Niewerth, S., Vogt, P., & Thewes, M. (2022). Tender evaluation through efficiency analysis for public construction contracts. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 1-11.
[69] Beljkas, Z., Prascevic, Z., Ivanisevic, N., Knezevic, M., & Cvetkovska, M. (2019). Application of fuzzy logic on selection of contractors for construction of high rise buildings. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 222, No. 1, p. 012021). IOP Publishing.
[70] Kasabreh, N. S. S., & Tarawneh, S. A. (2021). Investigating the impact of contractor’s performance on the success of Jordanian residential construction projects. International journal of construction management, 21(5), 468-475.
[71] Morkunaite, Z., Podvezko, V., Zavadskas, E. K., & Bausys, R. (2019). Contractor selection for renovation of cultural heritage buildings by PROMETHEE method. Archives of Civil and Mechanical Engineering, 19, 1056-1071.
[72] Morkūnaitė, Ž. (2019). Selection criteria for evaluating contractors of sgraffito technique in cultural heritage buildings.
[73] Morkūnaitė, Ž. Podvezko, V., & Kutut, V. (2017). Selection criteria for evaluating contractors of cultural heritage objects. Procedia Engineering, 208, 90-97.
[74] Fawzy, M. M., Elsharkawy, A. S., Khalifa, Y. A., & Hassan, A. A. (2024). Contractor selection by using multi-criteria decision-making for Egyptian road maintenance. International Journal of System Assurance Engineering and Management, 1-15.
[75] Hasnain, M., Thaheem, M. J., & Ullah, F. (2018). Best value contractor selection in road construction projects: ANP-based decision support system. International Journal of Civil Engineering, 16, 695-714.
[76] Marović, I., Perić, M., & Hanak, T. (2021). A multi-criteria decision support concept for selecting the optimal contractor. Applied Sciences, 11(4), 1660.
[77] Özyürek, İ., & Erdal, M. (2023). Crisp and fuzzy appraisal of tenderer’s qualifications in public works procurement in Turkey. Journal of Public Procurement, 23(1), 78-99.
[78] Alptekin, O., & Alptekin, N. (2017, October). Analysis of criteria influencing contractor selection using TOPSIS method. In IOP conference series: materials science and engineering (Vol. 245, No. 6, p. 062003). IOP Publishing.
[79] Bergman, M. A., & Lundberg, S. (2013). Tender evaluation and supplier selection methods in public procurement. Journal of purchasing and supply management, 19(2), 73-83.
[80] Lundberg, S., & Bergman, M. A. (2017). Tendering design when price and quality is uncertain. International Journal of Public Sector Management, 30(4), 310-327.
[81] Özyürek, İ., & Erdal, M. Ü. R. S. E. L. (2022). Solution Proposals based on Fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS Hybrid Model to the Problems in Public Works Procurement in Turkey. Turkish Journal of Civil Engineering, 34(1), 153-166.
[82] Aydın, D., & Mıhlayanlar, E. (2022). Determination of the significance of project delivery attributes (PDAs) on sustainable projects in Turkey. Journal of Engineering, Design and Technology, (ahead-of-print).

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics